Joseph Madenspacher was the district attorney, the county's top prosecutor at the time. "I think all the more she didn't do what she was convicted of.". Hazel Whitehead left her home 20 years ago today for what she thought was an appointment with her daughter's guidance counselor at school. Rainville said she did not want to discuss the personal details of Lambert's life. In a 1996 lawsuit, Lisa Michelle Lambert, 34, accused . An email has been sent to with a link to confirm list signup. Yunkin and Lambert got back together shortly after the holiday. PennLive file photo Harrisburg . The photograph at left is of Tabitha Buck when she was arrested for the 1991 murder of Laurie Show. Show's murder helped push forward anti-stalking legislation,[31] with new laws signed into effect in June 1993. The picture at left is Buck's current state prison photo. A federal judge agreed, briefly freeing Lambert from prison in a move that stunned many here. [5], On December 20, 1991, Laurie Show was discovered, fatally wounded, in her home by her mother. Just before Christmas 1991, Lambert and two accomplices schemed a way to attack and kill Show against whom Lambert had developed an unhealthy resentment. East Lampeter's police chief and a former detective have filed separate lawsuits claiming a book co-authored by convicted killer Lisa Michelle. As for the investigators and their misconduct, probes into the Lancaster District Attorneys Office and East Lampeter Township Police Department by the FBI, U.S. Attorneys Office, the state Judicial Conduct Board and Pennsylvania Attorney Generals Office all cleared the authorities that put Lambert away. "And she's lived an exemplary life in prison.". There is not a day that goes by that I dont talk about her in someway, said Whitehead. Rainville also made a point that Lambert would probably never step foot in Lancaster again for she is going to try and avoid the harassment that was bound to come with her freedom. But Laurie Show is forever 16, a pretty, dark-haired teen who was looking forward to getting her driver's license and hoped to some day be a nurse or a hairdresser. "It was so senseless, there was absolutely no reason that her life was taken, none what so ever" said Whitehead who, with Show's father, agreed to this interview to mark 20 years since the time they lost their daughter. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Yunkin was ordered to hold the sweatpants up against his body, which were shown to be too short for him, as well as being made of a different fabric from the garment entered into evidence in the 1992 trial. LANCASTER - John Show wanted the death penalty for Lisa Michelle Lambert in 1992, after a judge found the woman guilty of murdering his 16-year-old daughter with a butcher knife in a jealous rage over a man. No one to walk down the aisle. 19eO1#9A#Q2~! gffh0c/+m?Tk/vr^Z'8*Itis>T1r{uV^Y4?u J{O"o8Of8$OO-`7_&w0! [13] Buck was convicted of similar charges, and both young women were sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Zl~_jVG|5kR9x,7jsg_%L\84RQ5 `v.0%xxs_^1KB7ByvCz.gzS{> Uz'W`p H`.e@g-Z#/~1+g2\Pe/ E 7w:n`Y6Evpi)Ezf/5$Z'"n~sT {9CFIVA|KT6 uA W_c'4(YoaA m'Y]z3+$hxe#r0Y/.zy*G0 8'C~F>=g ]rI3mw8owsk9#K[mPtfgN_6{[{_b~U4+S >- BPz4\~u/& J)w0%szN27YU_Hw3NlR"4jEbUx{hBs.|qcg"QiByWP8=;WqI+A7t3[*26 *g tgdz>q"$1'_zHLc2. Click here if you wish to opt out and view the full site. If you disable cookies, this site will not work properly. Share: Email This BlogThis! The defense argued that Lambert had not participated in the act, that she had been sent out of the room by Yunkin, and that Lambert had unquestioningly obeyed Yunkins orders due to battered woman syndrome. Almost 10 months later, Lambert was returned to prison. The state Department of Corrections confirmed Tuesday that 45-year-old Tabitha Buck had been released on parole Saturday. District Attorney Craig Stedman, who will become a county judge in January, did not greet the prospect of Bucks release with enthusiasm. Show, 60, retired from his job working for a farm machinery manufacturer a few years ago, but then got called back to work. Show began spending time with Yunkin. I know John and Hazel are, as youve pointed out some facts in here that the media has neglected to share. Lambert was making new efforts to be released. The Lambert case consumed three years of her life, she said. Following her conviction, she also said she was raped by a prison guard. She has bounced around, spending time in prisons in Pennsylvania, Delaware, New Jersey and Massachusetts. Jack and Lisa Lambert are raising their kids on a 125-acre plot in the rural outpost of Worthington (population: 763), seven miles west of Kittanning. Faustnaut was a paramedic, who was familiar with Whitehead from working together at the hospital. What an interesting article. Exonerated in 1997. It took 45 minutes to outline his decision. She had studied at Santa Monica City College and was employed as the Ranch Manager at St. Bonnie's Animal. She claimed that three officers with the East Lampeter Township Police department raped her, causing them to frame her for the crime. She has stayed in the same condominium. Her attorney: Christina Rainville. [21] The third trial took place in May 1998, with a federal appeals court temporarily freeing Lambert under the belief that she would win her case. Cambridge Springs State Correctional Institution, "Teen's Slaying Killed Mother's Dreams but Fired Her Ambition", "Jealousy led teen to kill rival for boyfriend's affections", "LESSON DRAWN FROM TRAGEDY: A TEEN'S DEATH LEADS TO LEGISLATION", "A mother's loss, an unwavering crusade, and a small victory", "EERIE SLAY LINK - AMISH KILLER KNEW '91 TEEN MURDERERS", "Slain woman's relatives testify in court", "Appeals court mulls new trial in stalking murder", "AUTHENTICITY OF LETTER IN TEEN SLAYING DISPUTED", "Woman guilty of killing boyfriend's former date", "Convicted Pa. murderer wins $35,000 settlement", "Getaway driver in stalking murder gets out of prison", "Murder Suspect Says Death Is Preferable To Prison", "Federal court to decide whether Lambert can be freed", "Federal appeals court refuses to hear Lambert's request", "PA. SUPREME COURT SENDS LAMBERT BACK TO FIRST VENUE", "Federal appeals court orders Lambert's release", "Lambert tells prosecutor she tried to help victim", "Former boyfriend of stalking murderer testifies about abuse", "Witness: Defendant slit girl's throat as if 'cutting bread', "High court rejects appeal by woman convicted of stabbing teenage rival in 1991", "Slain teen's mother turns grief into war on stalking", "Timeline: The murder of Laurie Show, trials and appeals of co-conspirators Lisa Michelle Lambert, Tabitha Buck, and Lawrence Yunkin", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Murder_of_Laurie_Show&oldid=1126543781, December 1991 events in the United States, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 9 December 2022, at 22:50. Shows mother found her dying daughter, who was able to identify her killers. She received gifts, job offers, and every kind of help imaginable.. "She's just an exemplary person," Rainville said. According to Lambert her home life consisted of strict Christian parents with high morals. Because you are viewing this site from a location address that appears to be covered by the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 ("CCPA"), many of the features of TribLIVE.com -- like videos and social media elements -- are disabled. I don't know if I've totally figured out what it is, but I'll keep working at it.". [34], An hour-long special episode of 20/20 was aired in February 1999, featuring interviews with several former classmates who said that Lambert had made death threats against Show, as well as presenting evidence that one of the officers who allegedly raped Lambert was on a honeymoon during the time the alleged rape occurred. Wrongfully incarcerated lisamichellelambert.com Joined December 2020. Buck winces as she recalls the event. Lamberts partner, Tabitha Buck was a 17 year-old student at Penn Manor High School, who had transferred from Conestoga Valley a few months before the murder. Buck wrote herself a late note that day. The passion and severity behind the stalking offer a stark contrast to how Lambert later described her relationship with Yunkin. He keeps a low profile at his daughter's sporting events, watching their basketball games from the hallway, through a window on a gym door. I admire Mrs. Show-Whitehead for the strength she has displayed all these years. [24] Evidence from the 1997 re-trial was presented again. In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, 18-year-old Lisa Michelle Lambert waged a months-long campaign of harassment against 16-year-old Laurie Show in 1991. Lisa Lambert was born in 1962. She testified that Yunkin raped her daughter, and learned Michelle was pregnant shortly after. Ten months later, the release was overturned on a technicality. While in prison, Lambert earned a degree from Boston University, graduating with honors, Rainville said. It was 7:07, I wrote the teacher a note that said, I was here, if you need me I will come back,' added Whitehead. . "Not one bit," she said. TO READ A DOCUMENT, SIMPLY CLICK ONCE ON HIGHLIGHTED AREA & THIS DOCUMENT WILL OPEN FOR YOU TO READ. When in court Lambert stated that she had always been called by her middle name and her first was actually in fact, Lisa. In November Show and some friends went shopping at East Town Mall. The couple divorced in 2009, local court records show. Both Spangler and the attendance officer had to later testify in court. Investigators said she and Lisa Michelle Lambert killed the high school sophomore because Lambert saw Show as a romantic rival. The official video for Michelle Lambert - Come to MeDownload or stream here: http://smarturl.it/ComeToMeMLDirected by: Cedric Letsch (https://www.instagram.c. Her classmates Lisa Michelle Lambert, Tabitha Buck, and Lawrence "Butch" Yunkin were all subsequently charged . She was born July 27, 1958 in San . In the past two decades, Whitehead said she has had time to come to a certain sort of peace about what happened. Our system told victims families their case was over, and in many cases, for decades., The courts ruled and we follow the law, but that in no way diminishes the added emotional trauma this process has caused to those who have already suffered, he said. Lambert's Philadelphia attorneys, Christina Rainville and Peter Greenberg, accused prosecutors of moving Show's body to shoot bogus crime-scene photos, switching pieces of evidence, tampering with crime-scene videotapes and committing dozens of deceitful acts. 2. When Whitehead picked up Show she was in tears, Lambert and Yunkin had pulled up while the girls were outside and physically beat up Show. It likely will never be clear exactly who did what that morning of Dec. 20, 1991. It happened at 92 Black Oak Drive in East Lampeter Township. "I truly believe God has a plan for me. Yunkin went back to Lambert, who eventually became pregnant. Lambert doggedly appealed her case. Another time, Laurie told her mother that Buck threatened her at the mall. All rights reserved (About Us). because she briefly dated her boyfriend Lawrence 'Butch' Yunkin and she was jealous of Laurie By Lisa Michelle Lambert. It was during the teens final moments that she said she heard her daughter name her killer. On July 20, 1992, Michelle Lambert was found guilty of first degree murder and criminal conspiracy. At the time of Bucks release, Lambert was making new efforts to be released, but her docket sheets show the Pa. Supreme Court denied her 2013 petition for appeal. Greenberg remains retired, she said. They were scared, said Whitehead. Any other time they are nosy busy bodies, but that morning they chose not to go in and see whats wrong, said a choked-up Whitehead. Laurie sounded like such an incredible teenager/person, I believe you two would have become friends if she were here. James Eicher was ordered to spend up to three years in prison, and Lambert was moved to a New Jersey prison as a part of her relief. Official Account ran by best friend of Lisa and Lisa herself. Witnesses dropped out and evidence was prohibited. Request Answer. Success! Their rulings were overruled by other courts. [25] He also testified that he had seen a police officer, who matched one of the descriptions Lambert gave of her alleged rapists, give her a "threatening glare" at a local festival. Wiki User. These true crime movies and shows are about horrific Pennsylvania murders, scams and scandals, Can you help solve Harrisburgs 106-year-old Murder House case? At another store, Lambert and a group of friends reportedly approached Laurie and threatened her in front of her mother. Lambert claimed she had been framed by Lancaster police officers in order to keep her from coming forward with charges that they had gang-raped her. How old is Lisa Michelle Lambert? Yunkin claimed he didnt realize the gravity of what happened. After ending up on the later flight in the opening leg, Lisa & Michelle made quick enemies of Michael & Scott when the two teams squabbled over a spot on an earlier sea plane due to Michelle grabbing the pen for the sign-up board from Michael's hand, giving the sisters a bit of a cushion. The sighting matched up with a timeline Lambert was pushing in her defense, not what the original investigators were pushing, citing other witnesses. Yunkin's probation ends today, on the 20th anniversary of Laurie's killing. Lisa Michelle Lambert's book, "Love, Murder, and Corruption in Lancaster County: My Story," co-authored by Philadelphia attorney David Brown, will be published Feb. 15 by Camino Books. Clear & Convincing: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Vs She notified Whitehead and the police were called. "I just look back on the life that I had with Laurie, and the good times, and try to stay focused on that," she said. (AP Photo/Sabina Louise Pierce, File). More Local News to Love Start today for 50% off Expires 3/6/23. By December, it turned deadly. The three suspects and Lancaster County prosecutors agree on only two things: Laurie Show was killed, and all three suspects were involved in some way or another. Over the next decade, Lamberts appeals bounced around, including at one point landing back at Dalzell, who again swore to release her. Crucial points in the federal court never will be asked and will be removed from the record by witnesses convenient loss of memory.. Good luck. Police said Lambert saw Show as a romantic rival. Support local journalism. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. In the end, Stengel re-convicted Lambert, and although other appeal efforts were made she remains incarcerated today. [23], Lambert now testified that Yunkin had participated in the murders, choking Show. It was published on February 15, 2016, and can be found on Amazon. The film was directed by Norma Bailey and starred Jennifer Finnigan as Laurie Show. She gets up and faces every day and tries to make it the best she can. U.S. District Judge Stewart . She had a belief in God and enjoyed Bible study and Sunday school. For such a violent crime against Laurie Show, all three suspects should've had defensive wounds but Lisa Lambert had none. It was Lambert. [6] Dalzell also barred the state of Pennsylvania from re-trying Lambert. [9] Initial statements from the three claimed that Yunkin had dropped Lambert and Buck off at Show's house, where the two girls murdered Show. "It hurts," he said. Her parents, Leonard and Judy, obtained custody of the child. [10] Lambert and Buck would later recant their initial statements, with Lambert claiming that an abusive Yunkin had encouraged her to harass and assault Show. Hundreds of witnesses and pieces of evidence were expected from the defense, but the hearing did not go as planned. Whitehead called the police, who said nothing could be done because everyone had left the scene. As Laurie leaned a little bit further over, Tabitha saw her reach for a pair of scissors and knocked them out her reach. Since his release, newspaper records show he was a regular bowler at Garden Spot bowling alley in Strasburg, the same bowling alley where he bowled with Lambert and Buck before the killing and where he was arrested afterward. This has severely hindered her from seeing . But the justice system has already determined that two of the three have paid their debts to society. [26] They also questioned whether or not Show would have been able to speak to her mother before her death, as her throat had been cut, and alleged that Show had actually written out the initials of her murderers, Buck and Yunkin. Looking at pictures of Laurie, she always had a smile on her face and you could see that she was just a nice kid who didnt deserve this. The two young women burst inside and attacked Laurie. Ec207AcX/\? Find Lisa Lambert's phone number, address, and email on Spokeo, the leading people search directory for contact information and public records. n March 2, 2023 Whitehead feels her daughter's presence there, she said, when her television set and vacuum cleaner switch on by themselves or a light flickers. The victim was only 16 years old. The one allegation that helped solidify Dalzells opinion on the case came from Hazel Show a few days into the appeal hearing. Her body was discovered in her Lancaster, Pennsylvania, home by her mother Hazel Show with her throat having been slit. Lamberts attorneys were irate when they were told they could not cross-examine the investigative witnesses they were calling, nor could they treat them as hostile, which would have allowed further questioning of their testimony. Tuesday marks the 20th anniversary of the murder of 16-year-old Laurie Show, shown here in a file photo. . By December, it turned deadly. Despite the murder, it is the spot of her happiest memories with her daughter, she said, and she would not consider leaving it. Tabitha Buck is one of three people convicted in the grisly slaying of 16-year-old Laurie Show on Dec. 20, 1991. Rainville and Greenberg retired to Vermont in 2005, the same year that the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Lambert's case. Show and Yunkin had gone on a few dates, with Show reporting to her mother that Yunkin had date raped her. It catapulted onto the national stage in the late 1990s, when Lambert appealed her life sentence. Meanwhile, the Show family was devastated and began calling for the impeachment of Dalzell. nolead ends nolead begins. In pastoral central Pennsylvania, nobody knew what to do with Lisa Michelle Lambert. "The money doesn't matter but he should be made accountable for what he helped to do," she said. "You have to do your best to continue to do what you can to make your life better and to help others. The one who fought the hardest, and loudest, is still sitting in a cell. [15] Yunkin received a lesser sentence for his testimony and was granted parole in 2003. Critical assessment of the film was poor, with one journalist commenting that the film's depiction of both Laurie Show and Lambert distorted the true story. Buck and 18-year-old Lisa Michelle Lambert lured Show's mother out of their apartment and slashed Show's throat. No grandchildren to hold. [29] Federal Judge Anita Brody later upheld this verdict. In 1997, after a three-week federal hearing, U.S. District Judge Stewart Dalzell freed her, saying she was "actually innocent" and noting there was "wholesale prosecutorial misconduct" in the handling of her case. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). They hung out together. About a half hour later, the same person called again and told her to meet them at 7 a.m. the next morning at the junior high school. On the morning of December 21st, 1991, Hazel Show walked into her apartment to find her 16-year-old daughter Laurie, viciously murdered, her throat slashed and her body assaulted by multiple stab wounds. Error! The latest news from across Lancaster County, delivered first thing every morning. LISAMICHELLELA1@TWITTER. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. Lambert looked very pregnant that day it should be noted. Incredible article Taylor, were all so proud of you. ". Whitehead and Show also have not heard much about Buck in recent years. But Michelle Lambert didn't . Her name, Laurie Show. The bus usually picks her up around that time, said Whitehead. Police were involved and charges were pressed for simple assault. 2023 Trib Total Media | All Rights Reserved, Western Pennsylvania's trusted news source. After 28 years behind bars, Tabitha Buck, a midstate woman who was 17 when she killed a high school classmate is slated for release on Dec. 21. The allegations and the later conviction prompted Hazel to get involved in creating a stalking statute in the state criminal code. Yunkin claimed that when he picked them up, he noticed blood on Lamberts hand and helped her get rid of bloody clothing in the Susquehanna River at Arrowhead Marina.